{"citizen":{"id":"u1","name":"Personnage Paris 001 \u00b7 fictif","territoryId":"t1","familyId":"t1_family_1","familyLabel":"Famille fictive Paris 01","consent":true,"role":"citizen","suspended":false,"fictional":true,"history":[],"mind":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","revision":3,"round":2,"priorities":{"safety":0.933,"liberty":0.874,"ecology":0.843,"accessibility":0.742,"solidarity":0.604,"budget":0.277},"learningRate":0.14,"openness":0.458,"attachment":0.123,"uncertaintyTolerance":0.851,"initialTrust":0.401,"voice":11,"idiom":3,"dailyScene":"un rendez-vous qu\u2019on ne doit pas rater","beliefs":{"p1":0.05576,"p2":-0.00522,"p3":-0.06038,"p4":0.00175,"p5":0.05576,"p6":-0.00522,"p7":-0.06038,"p8":0.00175,"p9":0.05576},"experiences":2},"mindHistory":[{"round":0,"profile":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","revision":1,"round":0,"priorities":{"safety":0.933,"liberty":0.874,"ecology":0.843,"accessibility":0.742,"solidarity":0.604,"budget":0.277},"learningRate":0.14,"openness":0.458,"attachment":0.123,"uncertaintyTolerance":0.851,"initialTrust":0.401,"voice":11,"idiom":3,"dailyScene":"un rendez-vous qu\u2019on ne doit pas rater","beliefs":[],"experiences":0},"trigger":"Premi\u00e8re lecture, avant les retours fictifs."},{"round":1,"profile":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","revision":2,"round":1,"priorities":{"safety":0.933,"liberty":0.874,"ecology":0.843,"accessibility":0.742,"solidarity":0.604,"budget":0.277},"learningRate":0.14,"openness":0.458,"attachment":0.123,"uncertaintyTolerance":0.851,"initialTrust":0.401,"voice":11,"idiom":3,"dailyScene":"un rendez-vous qu\u2019on ne doit pas rater","beliefs":{"p1":0.01282,"p2":0.0436,"p3":-0.05178,"p4":-0.0101,"p5":0.01282,"p6":0.0436,"p7":-0.05178,"p8":-0.0101,"p9":0.01282},"experiences":1},"trigger":"Retours fictifs contradictoires, co\u00fbts et impr\u00e9vus ; aucune donn\u00e9e de terrain."},{"round":2,"profile":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","revision":3,"round":2,"priorities":{"safety":0.933,"liberty":0.874,"ecology":0.843,"accessibility":0.742,"solidarity":0.604,"budget":0.277},"learningRate":0.14,"openness":0.458,"attachment":0.123,"uncertaintyTolerance":0.851,"initialTrust":0.401,"voice":11,"idiom":3,"dailyScene":"un rendez-vous qu\u2019on ne doit pas rater","beliefs":{"p1":0.05576,"p2":-0.00522,"p3":-0.06038,"p4":0.00175,"p5":0.05576,"p6":-0.00522,"p7":-0.06038,"p8":0.00175,"p9":0.05576},"experiences":2},"trigger":"Retours fictifs contradictoires, co\u00fbts et impr\u00e9vus ; aucune donn\u00e9e de terrain."}]},"proposals":[{"id":"p1","title":"Pr\u00e9sence de proximit\u00e9 sur les cheminements fr\u00e9quent\u00e9s","territoryId":"t1","authorId":"u1","theme":"S\u00e9curit\u00e9 et pr\u00e9vention","summary":"Les usagers doivent pouvoir demander une aide de proximit\u00e9 sur les parcours fr\u00e9quent\u00e9s.","problem":"Les usagers doivent pouvoir demander une aide de proximit\u00e9 sur les parcours fr\u00e9quent\u00e9s.","cause":"Une pr\u00e9sence peu lisible aux horaires sensibles pourrait retarder l\u2019orientation et la m\u00e9diation.","consequence":"Une difficult\u00e9 d\u2019acc\u00e8s ou une exposition accrue au risque pourrait persister ; hypoth\u00e8se \u00e0 v\u00e9rifier.","solution":"Tester six mois de patrouilles p\u00e9destres de proximit\u00e9 et de points d\u2019information annonc\u00e9s, coordonn\u00e9s avec la pr\u00e9fecture de police, sans contr\u00f4le discriminatoire.","justification":"Comparer le pilote \u00e0 une p\u00e9riode de r\u00e9f\u00e9rence et discuter les biais. Comp\u00e9tence : Commune, avec coordination de la pr\u00e9fecture de police ; aucune comp\u00e9tence judiciaire nouvelle.","indicator":"D\u00e9lai m\u00e9dian d\u2019orientation vers un service comp\u00e9tent","risk":"D\u00e9placement du probl\u00e8me, co\u00fbt disproportionn\u00e9 ou acc\u00e8s in\u00e9gal : v\u00e9rifier les effets ind\u00e9sirables avant toute extension.","reversibility":"Pilote r\u00e9versible de six mois ; suspension en cas d\u2019atteinte aux droits ou de risque de s\u00e9curit\u00e9, bilan public contradictoire avant prolongation.","status":"consultation","version":1,"tags":["pr\u00e9vention","exp\u00e9rimentation r\u00e9versible"],"forecast":-20,"createdAt":"2026-10-01T08:00:00Z","sources":[{"id":"ssmsi","label":"SSMSI : statistiques communales 2024\u20132025, g\u00e9ographie 2026","url":"https:\/\/www.data.gouv.fr\/datasets\/bases-statistiques-communale-departementale-et-regionale-de-la-delinquance-enregistree-par-la-police-et-la-gendarmerie-nationales","type":"public_document","publishedAt":"2026-07-09","accessedAt":"2026-10-29","date":"2026-07-09"},{"id":"paris-police","label":"Paris : missions de proximit\u00e9, pr\u00e9vention et s\u00e9curit\u00e9 routi\u00e8re","url":"https:\/\/www.paris.fr\/pages\/tout-savoir-sur-la-police-municipale-parisienne-16970","type":"public_document","publishedAt":null,"accessedAt":"2026-10-29","date":"2026-10-29"}],"nodes":[{"id":"n0","category":"Probl\u00e8me","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Les usagers doivent pouvoir demander une aide de proximit\u00e9 sur les parcours fr\u00e9quent\u00e9s."},{"id":"n1","category":"Cause directe","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Une pr\u00e9sence peu lisible aux horaires sensibles pourrait retarder l\u2019orientation et la m\u00e9diation."},{"id":"n2","category":"Cause indirecte","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Hypoth\u00e8se : contraintes d\u2019organisation ou d\u2019acc\u00e8s aux services ; leur importance reste \u00e0 mesurer."},{"id":"n3","category":"Cause probable","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Cause probable \u00e0 tester, aucune causalit\u00e9 \u00e9tablie par la seule actualit\u00e9."},{"id":"n4","category":"Cause observ\u00e9e","kind":"observation","evidenceType":"public_document","content":"La Ville d\u00e9crit des missions municipales de proximit\u00e9, pr\u00e9vention et s\u00e9curit\u00e9 routi\u00e8re."},{"id":"n5","category":"Solution propos\u00e9e","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Tester six mois de patrouilles p\u00e9destres de proximit\u00e9 et de points d\u2019information annonc\u00e9s, coordonn\u00e9s avec la pr\u00e9fecture de police, sans contr\u00f4le discriminatoire."},{"id":"n6","category":"Cons\u00e9quence favorable probable","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Hypoth\u00e8se de baisse de 20 % de l\u2019indicateur ; objectif p\u00e9dagogique, aucune efficacit\u00e9 d\u00e9montr\u00e9e."},{"id":"n7","category":"Cons\u00e9quence d\u00e9favorable probable","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"D\u00e9placement du probl\u00e8me, co\u00fbt disproportionn\u00e9 ou acc\u00e8s in\u00e9gal : v\u00e9rifier les effets ind\u00e9sirables avant toute extension."},{"id":"n8","category":"Cons\u00e9quence observable","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Mesurer \u00ab D\u00e9lai m\u00e9dian d\u2019orientation vers un service comp\u00e9tent \u00bb avec protocole, dates et incertitude ; aucun r\u00e9sultat r\u00e9el disponible."},{"id":"n9","category":"Cons\u00e9quence impr\u00e9vue","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Un report vers d\u2019autres lieux ou publics est possible ; recueil contradictoire \u00e0 pr\u00e9voir."},{"id":"n10","category":"Solution alternative","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Renforcer les dispositifs existants sans cr\u00e9er de nouveau programme."},{"id":"n11","category":"R\u00e9vision","kind":"hypothesis","evidenceType":"hypothesis","content":"Pilote r\u00e9versible de six mois ; suspension en cas d\u2019atteinte aux droits ou de risque de s\u00e9curit\u00e9, bilan public contradictoire avant prolongation."}],"edges":[{"from":"n1","to":"n0","relation":"contribue \u00e0"},{"from":"n5","to":"n6","relation":"produit potentiellement"},{"from":"n5","to":"n7","relation":"produit potentiellement"},{"from":"n10","to":"n5","relation":"alternative \u00e0"}],"revisions":[],"priorityRank":1,"scope":"Commune, avec coordination de la pr\u00e9fecture de police ; aucune comp\u00e9tence judiciaire nouvelle.","simulated":true}],"votes":[{"id":"mv_c1_u1","consultationId":"c1","citizenId":"u1","choice":"abstention","at":"2026-10-12T12:00:00Z","history":[{"choice":"contre","at":"2026-10-10T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":1,"round":0,"digest":"12e8eaa4c1ee0f7c5972a813f23429a92ef0305337ff8024f04e2d83cab8ef27"}},{"choice":"abstention","at":"2026-10-11T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":2,"round":1,"digest":"c1b566493dd92704c295bf820016efd340e129b9fff2640257915bd780db466d"}}],"deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":3,"round":2,"digest":"9e6c710f86b92ab6e5e1fbbfb19b0a5730de1ccb45406bb27432c1d6c0bb23d0"},"simulated":true},{"id":"mv_c2_u1","consultationId":"c2","citizenId":"u1","choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-12T12:00:00Z","history":[{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-10T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":1,"round":0,"digest":"34d95a0d5cace5f82f98a22e69b13253c734f4faadce62e16e1f319a575a1aa7"}},{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-11T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":2,"round":1,"digest":"731bff23556976a0c9e22d6df3eeaf358c8de789989cef8645bdb7ad5522980e"}}],"deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":3,"round":2,"digest":"7d0a49be397a2c8bf93bd40b0ef9f89ec44997cea5a88052d3f3bb32899114b0"},"simulated":true},{"id":"mv_c3_u1","consultationId":"c3","citizenId":"u1","choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-12T12:00:00Z","history":[{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-10T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":1,"round":0,"digest":"9bb63bff4c3bcfeee566df1e9bd8da3e979079398aba63a8165ec7f5efb1eac7"}},{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-11T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":2,"round":1,"digest":"3fb3bb353bbc95dd8888eef8595bdb6929f33c25e42c6c652374ca23abb0ddd1"}}],"deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":3,"round":2,"digest":"6e163a38405f1050a5f0184549811b02365f6066833a1e7a1770bc9f9d1526d0"},"simulated":true},{"id":"mv_c4_u1","consultationId":"c4","citizenId":"u1","choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-12T12:00:00Z","history":[{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-10T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":1,"round":0,"digest":"75d26a688c4a06279b1e8b7bbbbc071cd97d5dc021e6f64b6d7cb0578da66662"}},{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-11T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":2,"round":1,"digest":"5d8b58259a62e1bad31eea2dbd72995b2f5b1f079f361553a6328b7773be54d0"}}],"deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":3,"round":2,"digest":"5f41d652f91db65f4162e2a4cc14c96af650c3499923bb2f9f06a039710fd731"},"simulated":true},{"id":"mv_c5_u1","consultationId":"c5","citizenId":"u1","choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-12T12:00:00Z","history":[{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-10T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":1,"round":0,"digest":"e9b863244a1d5ea013b5d1abd0893aaecba758e36432cba50eb659a5d5f6e2f2"}},{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-11T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":2,"round":1,"digest":"22852fddf65323101756098d7834c309419a5acf925479c946e31a455da21b9c"}}],"deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":3,"round":2,"digest":"5fbce1f42b36a9bc08eadeec6503c13f9346d14f73904daa01a8cf5d4b7ed20c"},"simulated":true},{"id":"mv_c6_u1","consultationId":"c6","citizenId":"u1","choice":"abstention","at":"2026-10-12T12:00:00Z","history":[{"choice":"abstention","at":"2026-10-10T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":1,"round":0,"digest":"ab38559fccbaa10a2d92d7680fb33fc6b6c15006a8682d6585036746eaa64824"}},{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-11T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":2,"round":1,"digest":"d092b36a26acbe114a0ee40120a994372acc7b2242f14b15d55661382e70f25b"}}],"deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":3,"round":2,"digest":"d0427d6ac4ff0d4f662c13ec109101c0860d82e35ca5c7188aa3411989053fc8"},"simulated":true},{"id":"mv_c7_u1","consultationId":"c7","citizenId":"u1","choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-12T12:00:00Z","history":[{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-10T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":1,"round":0,"digest":"b6c7f1492e43d840d46ae2dd32068e9769c1e6133570f09754deadc5a4be8752"}},{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-11T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":2,"round":1,"digest":"52277bf48755d18b64c82d1eec369b9c99995eef6233a1179e41f6943057242d"}}],"deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":3,"round":2,"digest":"3fccd19818b8e97fa3dfac5dd04c8dc225266d3a8b69113499e7a2b3a3c52667"},"simulated":true},{"id":"mv_c8_u1","consultationId":"c8","citizenId":"u1","choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-12T12:00:00Z","history":[{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-10T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":1,"round":0,"digest":"98c6b2d7fe4b94759e8e24de61cf572e920985a6438830d0385736f3c73eeacd"}},{"choice":"pour","at":"2026-10-11T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":2,"round":1,"digest":"2eb3569befa17bfaf25906697841fb9fd4fbce9e238ccefaa18faf16f1201499"}}],"deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":3,"round":2,"digest":"cc17079ba2168f99452abd466bf0530cd97fbae5fd2278c921ff17958f678908"},"simulated":true},{"id":"mv_c9_u1","consultationId":"c9","citizenId":"u1","choice":"contre","at":"2026-10-12T12:00:00Z","history":[{"choice":"contre","at":"2026-10-10T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":1,"round":0,"digest":"110b0195666cc9b091c370b3a54a9ab0a0707ebcb69b4c71c5c1ffa09cd5cb94"}},{"choice":"contre","at":"2026-10-11T12:00:00Z","deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":2,"round":1,"digest":"0710ed270abf3ba0701e74353c86c0c80545a74d3d80142e6b9ccc12541d74c0"}}],"deliberation":{"model":"fictional-mind-1","profileRevision":3,"round":2,"digest":"ea53dc853b27bbea1c244fe355040f01df73d1b4ba9ec448f462ddc4b20bd5e1"},"simulated":true}]}